* If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Best Hunting Arrows

Last Updated: February 26, 2020
Alexander Herbert
Product Review by Alexander Herbert

The performance and quality of your hunting arrow could mean the difference between center punching a deer’s lung or hitting the tree that he’s standing next to when you let your arrow fly.

Arrows might look the same, but their resemblance ends with aesthetics because they don’t offer the same cookie-cutter performance. Arrows vary extensively from brand to brand which matters a lot!

Shooting the right arrow is crucial for your success as a hunter. The best carbon hunting arrows are more reliable and have higher levels of accuracy – the end result is you being more successful in the field.

You should take into account the type of hunting that you’re most likely to do, along with the game you’re likely to go after. After that, simply fine-tune your individual set up on each arrow in your quiver to fly perfectly and penetrate as well as possible to ensure the best outcome.

Our Reviews

The Gold Tip Hunter Pro arrows provide extremely tight tolerances. The shafts are straightened to an incredible .001 inch while the weight only differs between 0.5 grains per inch. 

This arrow is perfect for competition and hunting thanks to its durable quality. Plus, this arrow comes with GTO nocks and bushings which makes it easy to use. 

The Hunter PRO arrows are made of 100% Carbon Technology. Are you a perfectionist? These arrows are the top choice for accurate 3D shoots. 

The premium price is worth it for the tighter tolerance that will provide you with the perfect shot which is what every hunter or archer wants! The shafts are light but they’re fantastic if you like to build your arrows with more FOC.

Pros

  • Premium product
  • Carbon technology
  • The strength of these arrows provide amazing strength sitatuon
  • Installed nocks

Cons

  • Not budget-friendly

This twelve-pack of arrows have removable tips. Some reviews say that the removable tips fall out easily however this can be fixed with glue.

These arrows are matte black with white fletching for identification. The extreme straightness and lightweight contributes to optimal accuracy in your hunting and target practice. 

Considering the low price, these arrows are a great choice for solidness and durability. 

The interchangeable heads are made of stainless steel and the carbon straight shaft strengthened to a Carbon grade level. 

The Musen Carbon Archery Arrows are suitable for draw weight 30-50lb recurve, compound and longbow. These arrows work great for hunting and target practice arrows for both youth and adults.

Pros

  • Sturdy enough for hunting and competition
  • Affordable
  • Tips are sharper than ever
  • Has great recurve
  • Anti-corrosive

Cons

  • Not suitable for professionals
  • Tips can fall out

The Easton Full Metal Jacket is a durable and small diameter arrow for hunters who prefer a heavier arrow. These arrows shed wind very well and fly nice and straight.

Easton achieves the heavier weight by using a smaller diameter combined with a thicker carbon fiber wall. The metal jacket is achieved by sheathing the shaft with a metal allow. This is designed so that the metal reduces friction in flight making it easier to pull. 

The full metal jacket is a fantastic choice of arrow with excellent prestige. For more penetration, add kinetic punch for thick hide & bone.

Pros

  • Easy target pull
  • HIT inserts
  • Metal jacket reduces friction
  • Heavier weight
  • Small diameter

Cons

  • Not suitable for beginners
  • Higher price point

For a mid-range shaft, the PileDriver holds excellent weight tolerances. The measured dozen has grains per inch of 10.725 which has been welcomed by many hunters that require a heavier arrow. 

The PileDriver cross bolts are made for the hunter that wants the ultimate bone-crushing penetration. These arrows have a heavier carbon bolt to create maximum kinetic energy and greater knockdown power. 

The PileDriver’s advanced construction ensures spine consistency for greater accuracy and the composite material is extremely durable at impact for exceptional reliability and performance. 

Every 6 pack of bolts comes with inserted moon nocks and an additional 6 universal flat nocks. Each bolt is precision sorted for straightness to ensure shot after shot consistency.

Pros

  • Heavy grain weight
  • Spine consistency for greater accuracy
  • Suitable for beginners
  • Budget-friendly

Cons

  • Not suitable for professionals

The Maxima Red carbon arrows are designed by Carbon Express with a state of the art design and are specifically aimed at providing enhanced broadhead accuracy and performance.

The shaft straightness is laser measured and sorted to a tolerance zone of only +/-0.0025 inches. The efficient spine is controlled to the point that only 2 spine sizes are required to meet draw weights from 40 to 81 pounds. 

The nock collars make them a great choice because you can put these arrows through significant wear and tear and the collars will provide protection to the nock.

Other great attributes on these arrows are the Blazer vanes, BullDog collars, and LAUNCHPAD nocks.

Pros

  • Dynamic spine control
  • Launchpad precision nock
  • Laser checked for straightness
  • Controlled arrow release
  • Budget-friendly

Cons

  • Box came a pretty damaged, the arrows were fine on the inside

How to Choose the Best Arrows for Hunting

There are lots of factors in nature that will always be out of your control. However, your equipment is one of the factors that you can control. Plus choosing the right arrow can make a real difference when it comes to performance.

Arrow diameter

The popularity of smaller diameter arrows has grown immensely over the past few years. Usually, the smaller the diameter of the arrow, the better the potential of penetration and the lower the opportunity for wind drift.

It’s important to keep in mind that as the arrow diameter is reduced, special insert systems are needed. Many insert systems require specialized attention for correct installation.

If you’re pondering over a micro or nano diameter shaft, ensure that you’ve researched all insert options to decide which best suits your needs.

Spine

Arrow spine is generally reflected in a three-digit number and referred to as deflection which is often printed on the arrow shaft itself.

Most often, you will find numbers ranging from 300 through to 500 depending on the arrow manufacturer. An arrow’s spine is measured by suspending a shaft over a 28” gap and hanging 1.94lb directly in the middle of the shaft.

When choosing the correct spine for your setup, you will need to consider factors such as arrow length and head weight. If an arrow is cut longer than 28” the spine will be weaker than the advertised measurement while an arrow cut short than 28” may result in increased stiffness.

Weaker shafts produce inconsistent arrow flight and performance.

Straightness Tolerance

Arrows can generally be broken down into three straightness categories: .006” .003” and .001” The key to this number is when most manufacturers measure this they are only measuring the middle 28” of the shaft. Shorter arrow lengths can sometimes lead to better consistency than longer lengths on the same shaft.

Distances under 40 yards with a .006” shaft will provide exceptional performance. However, you may notice that more arrows per dozen fly inconsistently.

For distances exceeding 50 yards, you will find a much better performance in a .003” shaft and even better in a .001” shaft.

Front of Center

Front of center (FOC) weight is the percentage of arrow weight on the front half of the arrow as measures from the perfect balance point.

If you’re considering building an arrow with a higher FOC, it’s important to consider your arrow spine. The more weight you add to the front of your arrow, the more you are weakening the spine. Therefore, you may need to upgrade a stiffer spine to achieve optimal performance from your bow.

Total weight

Arrow performance on arrows is variable depending on the impact angles to muscle density.

Generally, an arrow of upwards 400 grains will kill most things in North America, but certain situations will dictate for some improvisation.

Recap

Share the Love

If you found this post useful, please let others know about it by sharing it.